Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
A Litigation Management Proposal

Submitted by
Suchocki & Associates, PC
One Summit Avenue, Suite 312
Fort Worth, Texas 76102
(817) 338-0088
@copyright
2
Outline
  • Objective
  • The Management Method
  • Litigation Management: Definition
  • Representative Categories: To Be Defined
  • Litigation Management
    • Case Categories
    • Discovery Categories
    • Direct Reporting
  • Advantages for Management
3
Objective
  • To recommend a Management Method that can:


    • Maintain & increase quality of representation.
    • Provide comprehensive visibility to management.
    • Reduce overall litigation costs.
    • Create and maintain a plan for the disposition of each case.
    • Create a feed-back mechanism to provide growth, refinement
    •      and/or re-definition.
4
The Management Method
  •      The proposed management  method is a proven, effective method of managing a large project that provides control, visibility and accountability.


    • It  has a built-it mechanism for re-definition, growth, feed back and fine tuning.
    • This is a management tool used by NASA to define, develop and test the space shuttle software.
    • A firm member has personal experience with NASA development of space shuttle software.
    • Our firm has experience in implementing a form of this management method. We previously managed litigation for an elevator company throughout the State of Texas.
5
Litigation Management
Definition
    • We propose to apply the management method to Litigation Management.


    • Organize each case into a category, as a function of liability and damages.
    • Define and assign a discovery level for each category.
    • In addition to standard reporting, include a periodic personal briefing to management that will provide:
      • Visibility as to number of cases in each category.
      • Current accounting of attorney fees and costs.
      • Critical reporting of major cases and category changes.
      • Attorney accountability for case development.
      • Discussion of problems, strategy and goals.
      • An ongoing forum to control costs.
      • A basis for an action plan for case disposition.
6
Representative Categories
To be Defined
  • Liability
    •   0 to 20%       Minimal Risk
    • 20 to 40%       Acceptable Risk
    • 40 to 60%   Equal Risk
    • 60 to 80%   High Risk
    • 80 to 100%   Unacceptable Risk


  • Damages
    • Less that 10K       D1
    • 10K to 50K     D2
    • 50K to 100K D3
    • 100K to 250K  D4
    • 250K to 500K D5
    • 500K to 1M D6


7
 Litigation Management
Case Categories
  • Category One
    • Minimal Risk with D1- D2 Damages
    • Level 1 Discovery
    • Nuisance Settlement or Trial


  • Category Two
    • Minimal Risk with D2-D5 Damages
    • Level 2  Discovery
    • Defense Cost Settlement or Trial


  • Category Three
    • Minimal Risk with D5 or Greater
    • Level 3  Discovery
    • Demand                         Risk
8
 Litigation Management
 Case Categories

  • Category Four
    • Acceptable Risk with D1-D4 Damages
    • Level 2  Discovery
    • Defense Cost Settlement or Trial


  • Category Five
    • Acceptable Risk with D4 or Greater
    • Level 3  Discovery
    • Demand                         Risk
9
Litigation Management
 Case Categories

  • Category Six
    • Equal Risk with D1-D4 Damages
    • Level 2  Discovery
    • Defense Cost Settlement or Trial



  • Category Seven
    • Equal Risk with D4 or Greater
    • Level 3  Discovery
    • Demand                         Risk

10
Litigation Management
 Case Categories
  • Category Eight
    • High Risk with D1-D3 Damages
    • Level 4  Discovery
    • Demand                         Risk




  • Category Nine
    • High Risk with D3 or Greater Damages
    • Level 4  Discovery
    • Mediation


11
Litigation Management
 Case Categories

  • Category Ten
    • Unacceptable Risk with any  Damages
    • Level 4  Discovery
    • Mediation

12
 Litigation Management
Discovery Categories
  • Level 1
    • Interrogatories; Production; Admissions; Disclosure
    • Medical, Personnel Records and Photographs
    • Non-Stenographic Deposition of Plaintiff
    • Telephone Interview  of Witnesses


  • Level 2
    • Interrogatories; Production; Admissions; Disclosure
    • Medical, Personnel Records and Photographs
    • Deposition of Plaintiff
    • Interview/Deposition of Witnesses
13
 Litigation Management
 Discovery Categories
  • Level 3
    • Interrogatories; Production; Admissions; Disclosure
    • Medical, Personnel Records and Photographs
    • Deposition of Plaintiff
    • Mediation
    • Deposition of Critical Witnesses
    • Medical/Liability Expert, as necessary


  • Level 4
    • Interrogatories; Production; Admissions, Disclosure
    • Medical, Personnel Records and Photographs
    • Deposition of Plaintiff
    • Depositions of Critical Witnesses
    • Liability Consultant
    • Mediation/Settlement
14
Litigation Management
 Direct Reporting to Management
  • Periodic reporting to management by defense attorneys to include such items as:
    • Comprehensive report of status of all cases in manageable format.
      • Number and category of cases.
      • Red flags, problems & concerns.
      • Cases set for trial.
      • Disposition dates for each case.
      • Summary of ongoing costs and project costs, per case and total.
    • Visibility for significant litigation.
    • Forum for discussion of strategy and options.
    • Forum for discussion of  methods to control costs.
    • Overall budget control.
    • Action item list for follow up.
15
Advantages For Management
  • Provides Management  the opportunity for direct review and input into defense strategies on a cooperative level.
  • Defense counsel is directly accountable for explaining status, rationale and strategy.
  • Provides visibility into significant cases for both liability/damages and costs.
  • Strengthen the relationship of trust, understanding and loyalty between defense counsel and client.
  • Provides comprehensive visibility into all litigation for a section of Texas.
  • Provides a direct means of controlling overall litigation costs.
    • Develop a working relationship and guideline for cost control
    • Guard against protracted and unnecessary discovery
    • Generate and maintain statistics on average  cost per case
  • Provides a goal oriented disposition plan for each case